
Manchester City 2-4 Manchester United
By Catherine MacKenzie for Impetus (19/01/25).
Above: Manchester United celebrate one of their four goals. Photo: @ManUtdWomen on X
Rudderless Manchester City were taken apart by hattrick hero Ella Toone in an explosive Manchester derby
The race for top three is on
As the game kicked off, the race for a top three finish in the Women’s Super League (and therefore Champions League football next season) was on. In first and second place, Chelsea and Arsenal both won their first league matches of 2025 by large margins; Chelsea dismantling West Ham five-nil, whilst Arsenal won against Crystal Palace by the same scoreline. Heading into the evening’s Manchester derby, this provided an added pressure for both teams, with managers Gareth Taylor and Marc Skinner both needing valuable points to stay in the race.
Injury-plagued City needed a leader
Manchester City have been plagued by long-term injuries this season, and captain Alex Greenwood, Lauren Hemp and top scorer Khadija Shaw were all missing for this game. United were relatively healthy, with a minor knock relegating Grace Clinton to the bench for most of the game. However, City had been active in the transfer market – such as bringing in Vivianne Miedema – and whilst you will always miss players like Hemp, Greenwood and Fowler, it is arguable that they were still favourites to win the game.
Instead, their major fallback seemed to be based on leadership. As United stormed to a fiery start (scoring three goals in quick succession), City looked completely broken down, and nobody appeared to want to step up and lead the team. They were rudderless, missing Greenwood’s direction – either shouting orders or playing key passes through the midfield.

Above: Manchester City commiserate following the final whistle. Photo: @ManCityWomen on X
Individual mistakes changed the game
City had most of the possession and created many chances. They did not look bad going forward; Miedema looked energetic and Roord also had a few chances. However, defensively it was a horror show. In goal, Khiara Keating had an extremely unfortunate time, making two major mistakes that cost City goals. Her confidence looked shaken after United’s second goal, and it is here that City were missing Greenwood’s leadership – someone to pick up Keating and give her a word of confidence.
United picked up on this lack of confidence plaguing City’s back line and took every chance they could. They seemed to win every duel, went after every ball and there was a sense that United wanted the win more. Riviere dealt with Mary Fowler effectively, and the midfield trio of Toone, Miyazawa, and Janssen protected United’s back line well. In contrast, although they were impressive in an attacking sense, City’s midfield looked lost, with wayward passes and lazy interceptions (Fujino was the exemption to this).
One question that should perhaps be asked of Gareth Taylor is his lack of substitutes – two were made, and these came relatively late, on 76’ and 85’ minutes. City were fatigued by this point, and their frustration showed in some less-than-stellar decision-making.

Above: Ella Toone with her hattrick ball. Photo: @ManUtdWomen on X
Ella Toone, Hattrick Hero
Ella Toone has had a difficult start to the season and succumbed to injury in late 2024. Her return in the FA Cup match against West Brom was sealed with a goal, and during that game it looked like she was playing with a renewed sense of freedom. That feeling continued into the derby, and she was ferocious in her quest for goals.
A word also needs to be reserved for the unselfishness of Elisabeth Terland. Terland was in a position to shoot more than once, preferring an unselfish pass to a teammate (often Toone). Bizet had a lot of luck producing crosses from the left and put in a huge shift defensively. Tullis-Joyce produced some very good saves and dealt with set pieces and corners well.
United were not reliant on Toone, and this was the first time this season that they performed well as an entire team, with not one weak element.
What this means for both teams
City do not have to wait long for a chance at revenge, as they visit Leigh Sports Village on Wednesday to play United in the League Cup. However, tonight’s game was definitely the more important of the two meetings; United missed out on Champions League football this season and have to aim for a top three finish. With Chelsea still unbeaten and Arsenal gaining momentum under new manager Renee Slegers, it looks like the final spot will come down to a battle between the Manchester clubs, making these three points all the more valuable.
Teams: MANCHESTER CITY (4-1-3-2): Keating, Casparij, Aleixandri, Knaak, Ouahabi, Hasegawa, Fujino, Roord, Fowler, Miedema, Park. Substitutes: Blindkilde-Brown (for Miedema 77’), Murphy (for Park 85’), Yamashita, Annets, Davies, Prior, Coombs, Oyama.
Scorers: Miedema 40’, Knaak 45+3’
MANCHESTER UNITED (4-2-3-1): Tullis-Joyce, George, Turner, Le Tissier, Riviere, Janssen, Miyazawa, Bizet, Toone, Galton, Terland. Substitutes: Middleton-Patel, Sandberg (for George 65’), Malard (for Terland 65’), Clinton (for Toone 77’), Williams (for Bizet 85’), Mannion, Awujo.
Scorers: Toone 14’, 36’, 46’, Galton 21’
Referee: Lisa Benn
Attendance: 43,615.


